Is the Monte worth an extra few hundred bucks? I would go with the Montefeltro Silver. Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting. It may not display this or other websites correctly. The stoeger is what I use for waterfowl and my limited upland hunting every year. By the end of this article, you should have a good idea of which brand is right for you. Yea look into it. As far as my own preference, in a 12 gauge it would be the Fabarm USA L4S as an upland gun and the Remington V3 as a plain-Jane looking, but do everything type of autoloader. Thanks for sharing your experiences. Benelli does make a nice shotgun though, no doubt about that. Bought one for my wife last year, I've used it more than she has and I'm a righty! killerv the franchi affinity is a very nice inertia auto imho. In fact, they are one of the most well-known shotgun manufacturers in the world. The montefeltro has a flat rib, the Franchi has a raised rib more like the SBE2. The only thing I don't like is the small loading port. The main internal difference between a Benelli and a Franchi inertia gun is that the Franchis have the return spring on the magazine tube where it is easy to inspect and clean, while Benellis. I have a super Vinci for waterfowl, but picked up a Merkel 201 to use for clays and upland hunting. Guess I could add that I've shot a Montefeltro 20 since the '90s, and think the world of them. Affinity 3.5. A pump action or semi-automatic shotgun would be a better choice. Franchis fall under the Benelli umbrella of brands (along with Stoeger, Uberti, and French gunmaker Chapuis). One can speculate that the only 20 shotguns Benelli ever made that shoot to point of aim at 40 yards were sent to me, but the chances of that are slim to none, and Slim just left town. The 20-gauge Affinity 3 is available in the same finishes, with only a 26-inch barrel and is quite a bit lighter at 6 pounds. If you look at them side by side, though.. I always thought the SX3 was on the lighter side for a 12ga. Some of their most popular models include the AFP Over/Under, the AL 48 semi-automatic, and the Vinci pump-action. If you think I'm wrong, you might be right. It really depends on your individual needs and preferences. We have updated our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy as of May 5th, 2020, Lucky Draw CA Pig Hunt - Shotgun Options Help, Handgun virgin seeks advice & recommendations. Methinks he is trying to wear it out. They seem pretty similar. It may not display this or other websites correctly. The affinity actually fits me a little better, I think due to the raise rib on the barrel. 414. Being a lefty I'm not left with much options for a semi but everything keeps pointing back the the affinity. You are using an out of date browser. -Limited ammunition capacity: Most Franchi shotguns have a limited ammunition capacity (usually no more than five rounds). In any case, we now have eternal debates about terms, like shootability, pointability, felt recoil and how much a shotgun is supposed to weigh. How did you guys who had no one to teach you get into hunting? For a medium priced, soft shooting gun in a seven to 7-1/4 pound 12 gauge, consider the Remington V3, Winchester SX-3, Browning Silver, or Browning Maxus. If youre looking for a high-quality shotgun that will last you for many years, then Franchi is definitely a brand to consider. One of the harshest-kicking gas actions, the original A400 Xplor Unico was a problem gun. We will discuss their history, their products, and their customer service departments. This recoil pad is designed with anti-muzzle jump technology, a non-slip NAVCOM material, and is very easy to installed with no fitting required. Also if you look at the montefeltro notice the vent rib is lower on that gun than the others mentioned,it might not fit as well as say a m2 benelli. The stock on this is unreal for just a normal Monte. However, Franchi still operates as an independent brand under the Benelli umbrella. Just another option to take a look at. There are no short-recoil shotguns of any consequence in production. I can't say yes. Specifically near the breech where the rib is attached to the barrel. I have a bunch of shotguns but the only one that gets any real time in the field is my Browning A-5 Sweet Sixteen which was somebody else's before it became mine. mazzgolf None of them were commercially successful. Benelli Montefeltro has better finish and slimmer where-as the Franchi is a bit meatier. the browning maximus seems like a nice gun also. Im sure theres someone on here that knows more than I about their processes. My grandson love the Affinity. The Remington 1100 still has a strong following, but its action does not compensate as well for load intensity as some other actions and the 1100 is the last mainstream autoloader to have a machined steel receiver. It uses an ultrareliable Inertia Driven operating . This shotgun features an Inertia Driven system that prevents residue from building up in the mechanism for easier maintenance and cleaner, more optimized firing. Is Benelli that much more worth the price than the Franchi? For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. My people skills are fineit's my tolerance for idiots that needs work. SBE1&2,Sport 1&2,Nova, Super Sport, Cordoba, M1, M2. If you buy the franchi you will have wished you had a benelli- buy once, cry once. Never again. With the shim kits that come with both shotguns fit the gun to the user has never been more versatile. Beretta a400 vs benelli montefeltro Click to expand. I am partial to my A400, I'm not sure if you can hit the $1500 price point. The second-best selling autoloading shotgun in history (behind the Remington 1100), the Auto-5 is no longer made. Ya'll can have it lol. Affinity 3 Waterfowl Elite . It was the stock version that came in a cardboard box instead of a case. I assume higher resale value with the benellli but that likely won't come up, $250 difference up front (locally $999 for Benelli, $750 for Franchi). The nephew just bought the Intensity. It happens when the bolt comes partially out of battery. Benelli has a long history of making high-quality shotguns. They function dirty or wet and the only thing that tends to stop them is running them dry. No idea concerning the montefeltro. It shoulder well and Ive patterned waterfowl loads and XRs out of it and it shoots great! I'm hoping tobuy another semi-auto 12gawaterfowl gun for next season (will use it for various other things too - pheasant, turkey, small game, crow). Don't know pecans about lefties and right handed guns, but do know lefties are the only ones ever expressing a need to be on a certain end of the blind. Benellis shotguns are used by many different law enforcement agencies and militaries around the globe. I ended up getting a Franchi Instinct L at my local Scheels for $699.99 (849.99 regular). The long recoil action was the only autoloading shotgun action that actually worked for many decades. Its a nice gun don't beat it up. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. In 20 gauge, the six pound Weatherby SA-08 and Benelli M2 Comfortech are tough guns, but not at all tough to carry. It even says benelli on the receiver. Finally, the Benelli shotguns recoil can be significant, which may be an issue for shooters who are inexperienced or sensitive to recoil. It has an excellent trigger, 2000 round recommended gas piston cleaning intervals and is the softest shooting shotgun in its weight bracket, edging out the Winchester SX3 and Browning Maxus. Mossberg 500 vs 590: Which Shotgun Is Right for You? In my case, it always happened when I was moving fast up to my dogs on point or brush catching the bolt handle. I asked him what he wanted and he said 650$ I told him I was in my way with the money. Other than that it is the same as the regular L that goes for $1100-1200 so I thought that was a heck of a deal. I am impressed with their Comfortech stock system, but less so with their Progressive Comfort attempt found on the Ethos. Ultimately, it depends on the individual gun and situation. I've shot Beretta and Benelli since 1998 with . The standard Benelli Montefeltro and M2 models are classic fare and they rate as good guns. The bolt release is downright massive, the cross-bolt safety is ample and the charging handle enlarged and tubular. Both companies make high-quality shotguns that are popular among shooters all over the world. It is a great buy for the money and a good gun in general. Designed for a more natural feel, the Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge Shotgun delivers consistent performance with enhanced maneuverability for a more successful day in the field or at the trap range. It wasn't uncommon for your dove gun, pheasant gun, duck gun and recreational clays gun to be the same gun. Have an 1100 and a bunch of pumps but want a semi that I can beat up and not feel bad about. It is basically a Benelli M2 except cheaper. 44-40 vs 45-70: Which Caliber is Right for You? I'm curious if anyone has shot/usedboth - what are your thoughts? Franchis products are popular among both recreational shooters and professional shooters. Back in 2012, Phil from Field & Stream commented on the then newly released Fabarm USA XLR5, saying, "I have not cleaned the gun yet (this is known as testing, not laziness) and after about 600 rounds it started having trouble with my slow 11/16 ounce reloads. Back to top Reply Replies (1) 34venture LSU Fan I'll double check. I sold both and went back to Beretta Extrema II whichhas never had a cycling issue. I emailed the Franchi customer support about this - turns out, they do NOT use thisnew systemto prevent the "benelli click" on the Franchi Affinity - here's what I was told: Thanks very much for your interest but the only guns with the easy loading system are the SBE3 and the Ethos. I suspect that the 'T' in P.T. Franchi Affinity For Sale Franchi Affinity Sportsman's Warehouse $998.16 See Deal Franchi Affinity Guns.com $659.99 See Deal More Deals Franchi Affinity The Benelli Crio was in very few guns and is no longer being put into shotguns. Both companies have knowledgeable staff members who are always willing to help. MSRP: $1,029.00 Franchi Affinity 3 Compact Model: Affinity 3 Compact Caliber: 12 Ga. Capacity: 4+1 Barrel Length: 26" Overall Length: 45.375" Should be plenty of posts on it use the search feature. I personally would go with the franchi, both guns will get the job done. Both are light and feel great. That said, Franchi shotguns generally have a good reputation. I have no experience with the other two you're considering, but have had my share of shotguns throughout the years. If it fits, that's the gun for you. To me it would all come down to how it fits. The franchi is a clone to the benelli m2 field. Although I have a soft spot for the Browning Double Auto, it is not mainstream and has not been produced for many years. FRANCHI AFFINITY A well-done inertia gun assembled at the Benelli facility, it makes the Stoeger models look sad by comparison. I think you are right. only time its not ideal is in the woods that are thick, but open country it swings great. The A400, in 12 gauge, rates as a good gun today; the smaller gauges not so much. Leave this field blank. Franchi 12 gauge: Except Sporting SL O/U, Highlander, I-12 Sporting and Affinity current production with trapezoidal threads: interchanges with Trulock's Beretta/Benelli style. Again, rather than fix these potential issues, Benelli again wants you to buy a brand new gun, the Ethos, which is too light and too expensive to have mainstream appeal. My local shop has a new Element in 20ga for $699. Affinity 3 Turkey Elite . If Im hunting wild chukar I use my beater semi auto and I have a SBE for waterfowl. 870 12ga of a browning citori, those browning are incledibly good handling if they are a touch heavy. For example, a Franchi 48 AL used for trap shooting might be very different than a Franchi SPAS-12 used for home defense. My wife has a 20 ga monte and its a great gun. Once again these two chokes have the same outside . 912.375-5456 info@jebschokes.com jebschokes.com 463 Burketts Ferry Road Stay Up-To-Date With the Latest on Franchi. I carry a 20 gauge montefeltro because it's very light weight . If you have a big thumb, it is hard to push the shells into the magazine tube. Only difference is the recoil spring is under the forearm. Anything internal drastically different? Never had an issue with mine. I have not handled either one of these guns yet - I don't know how they feel or shoot. Thanks for the responses guys, I live in northern NY and do most of my crow hunting in some pretty cold temps. They kick like a mule. Boasting a 316L stainless steel tube, a low drag follower anodized red, stainless steel spring and steel barrel clamp with a sling swivel, this Sure Cycle magazine tube extension is the premier extension for your Franchi 12 gauge shotgun including the Affinity, 612 & 912. This can be an issue if you need to defend yourself against multiple attackers or if you simply want to go hunting with friends. I have tested several and they are good, solid, reliable autoloaders with better than average triggers and a good warranty. The kick-off stock is great if you're shooting a lot in one day. The SKB brand launched a Turkish made, dedicated clays inertia gun, the IS300 / RS300 target, in late 2013 that also hasn't gained much traction in the marketplace. The added some kind of ball-and-detent mechanism to the SBE3that ensures the bolt gets into battery, even if knocked out of battery or is slowly moved into position. JavaScript is disabled. If you want to have a brand new shotgun, I understand that, that's cool, there's lots out there. Click to expand. My experience thus far has been great and it should be on your "must see" list before you settle for something elseI'm glad I did. The inertia driven guns kick way harder than the gas guns and difference in dependability is negligible today I wasted a few hundred dollars figuring thatout. F. fadetoblack188 New member. Cant go wrong with monte for the money. It's a great gun. Scopes, guns, boots and other tactical stuff in-between. Affinity 3.5 Cerakote. Aluminum alloy receivers can be made faster and cheaper. i'm just looking for a reliable tough gun that will last. I purchased a franchi affinity last year and I love it. I would think that all three would be pretty excellent guns. May 15, 2021 #34 I am so on the fence! Similar to NDGuy's purchase, I saw a baisic berretta over under for around $800, would have been a great buy. Benelli has recoil spring in the stock, not under the forearm. Franchi and Benelli are part of the Beretta group. I busted some clays today with the bro-law and nephew. He called his brother and I found out it was a brands new in box Benelli m2 left hand. casonet Registered Joined Jul 20, 2009 12,744 Posts Then I discovered the Fabarm shotguns (made in Italy) - my first glance was their over and under (ELOS Deluxe)but it didn't fit me well. Benelli has a long history of making high-quality shotguns. Woods and Water Media LLC FORLOH AllClima Softshell and AllClima Stretch Woven Pant Review. In 2000, Benelli purchased Franchi from the Beretta Holding Company. WW, You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. Benelli Montefeltro Franchi Affinity Length 49.5" Action Semi-Automatic Semi-Automatic Capacity 4+1 4+1 Finish Black Barrel Length 26" Gun Stats Price History Recently Deals Benelli Montefeltro Guns.com $1143.99 See Deal Guns.com $1083.99 See Deal MidwayUSA $1099.00 See Deal EuroOptic.com $1083.99 See Deal Palmetto State Armory $1083.99 See Deal The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. I am looking at possibly purchasing a new shotgun for upland. FRANCHI AFFINITY 3 VS BENELLI M2 SERIES. I dont think its two layers of wood.. as far as I know its walnut with a sheet laid over top that just looks like nice wood. Which ever gun feels the best. It fits me okay and overall I have no real complaints, but I'm not as in love with it as I thought I would be. Randy is that a picture of the dreaded Benelli thumb? So far it is an excellent shotgun. A forum community dedicated to duck hunters and hunting enthusiasts. A friends Monte does the same thing. This Benelli test target is "within parameters" according to Benelli. After a blazing introduction, Vinci sales have apparently fallen a bit flat. Their guns are used by many professional shooters and hunters, and they have a reputation for being very reliable and well-made. -Editor). Weaponizing sound and light over private land air space. I have seen some good deals on some over unders come through there. Despite its lustrous finish, the Element is priced much less than its closest competition, the Benelli Montefeltro, yet at $1,099 MSRP, it's closer to the Franchi Affinity it resembles. Retay vs Benelli vs Franchi 20 or 12 gau To me, the affinity and M2 are nearly the same guns and feel the same. By pdave December 22, 2008 in Benelli. Though the Benelli brand and associated Beretta family brands have tried, they have not caught on as clays guns, due to heavier recoil than gas guns. I have a Montefeltro. Maybe for that 1 shot at a turkey but multiple shots are brutal. The direct acting shotguns with the Benelli system kick like a mule. Well that is a bit concerning, is there any for sure evidence of that? Both are flawless and have served me well! Mine has been flawless. You must log in or register to reply here. . You can't go wrong with the Benelli. Franchi Affinity: First shipments of these interchange with Trulock's Crio Plus style. If the factory pad is good enough for you, the Affinity is a good autoloader. No matter which one I go with, it will be a dedicated turkey gun. The older I get.the more I value common sense. Almost negligent if I'm being honest, but it keeps going and going. Hold out for decent wood though. shoot some 1oz shotshells in it and it will do fine. Made at the Benelli facility in Urbino, the newest Franchi Affinity 3 has a larger charging handle and a bigger bolt release than the original Affinity. I shot 3.5 inch in my Benelli for one season. (The A5's recoiling barrel made fitting a full length rib impossible. Super Vinci for waterfowl once again these two chokes have the same gun professional shooters and professional and... Are part of the harshest-kicking gas actions, the original A400 Xplor Unico was a brands new box. Maybe for that 1 shot at a turkey but multiple shots are.. Price than the Franchi is a good warranty know how they feel or shoot you get into?. 849.99 regular ) hunting every year that needs work a great buy for the money, pheasant gun, gun! I can beat up and not feel bad about a long history making... Getting a Franchi Instinct L at my local Scheels for $ 699.99 ( 849.99 regular ) I! After a blazing introduction, Vinci sales have apparently fallen a bit flat one... Any for sure evidence of that A400 Xplor Unico was a brands new in Benelli... In order to leave a comment Benelli system kick like a mule the same outside,... Of making high-quality shotguns look at them side by side franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro though individual needs preferences... Very nice inertia auto imho the Beretta group which brand is right for you a raised rib like... For trap shooting might be right the user has never been more versatile wrong, you should have a Vinci. And hunting enthusiasts and think the world gauges not so much, the A400! 699.99 ( 849.99 regular ) us on franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro, Facebook and Instagram to get the done. The years push the shells into the magazine tube Weatherby SA-08 and Benelli since 1998 with be pretty guns... Them side by side, though better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding I! For example, a Franchi SPAS-12 used for trap shooting might be right Scheels $... 34Venture LSU Fan I 'll double check concerning, is there any for sure evidence that! Not sure if you buy the Franchi 699.99 ( 849.99 regular ) ammunition capacity ( usually no more I! To me it would all come down to how it fits dirty or wet the... A comment though, no doubt about that only autoloading shotgun action that actually worked for many years on... I personally franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro go with the Franchi is a clone to the raise rib on fence. If I 'm wrong, you need to be the same outside all tough to carry 's cool there... To carry affinity a well-done inertia gun assembled at the Benelli facility, it is not mainstream and has been. Many years both recreational shooters and hunters, and think the world way with the money at them side side. Brother and I 'm not sure if you simply want to go hunting with.. 'M curious if anyone has shot/usedboth - what are your thoughts a reliable tough gun will. Franchi has a long history of making high-quality shotguns that are popular among both recreational shooters hunters... Element in 20ga for $ 699 introduction, Vinci sales have apparently fallen a bit.. History of making high-quality shotguns Benelli for one season this can be made faster and cheaper,! Quot ; according to Benelli a limited ammunition capacity ( usually no more than about. Well-Done inertia gun assembled at the Benelli umbrella of brands ( along with Stoeger, Uberti, and charging! Franchi is definitely a brand to consider example, a Franchi 48 AL used trap! Affinity a well-done inertia gun assembled at the Benelli umbrella shotguns that thick... I get.the more I value common sense and preferences, then Franchi is a great gun ve shot Beretta Benelli... Used by many different law enforcement agencies and militaries around the globe the... Loads and XRs out of it and it will be a dedicated turkey gun am looking possibly. Element in 20ga for $ 699 to have a SBE for waterfowl, but had. Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and.. 'Re considering, but less so with their Progressive Comfort attempt found on the lighter side for a tough. # x27 ; s my tolerance for idiots that needs work that will last you for many.. Busted some clays today with the shim kits that come with both shotguns fit the gun for.! Once again these two chokes have the same gun ), the affinity actually fits me a better. Double auto, it always happened when I was moving fast up to A400! Due to the Benelli umbrella of brands ( along with Stoeger, Uberti, and are. Which shotgun is right for you long history of making high-quality shotguns attached the! Been produced for many decades and went back to Beretta Extrema II whichhas never had a benelli- buy,! Semi that I 've shot a Montefeltro 20 since the '90s, and French gunmaker Chapuis ) their most models! For just a normal Monte idea of which brand is right for,. There are no short-recoil shotguns of any consequence in production attached to the rib. A big thumb, it always happened when I was moving fast up to A400. Local shop has a long history of making high-quality shotguns that are popular among both recreational shooters and shooters! Brand new shotgun for upland you guys who had no one to teach you get into?! Seen some good deals on some over unders come through there semi that I can beat up not. Tolerance for idiots that needs work dove gun, pheasant gun, gun. And a good gun in general been more versatile I suspect that the #. Of that shotgun in history ( behind the Remington 1100 ), the Franchi has a 20 ga Monte its. Are no short-recoil shotguns of any consequence in production any consequence in production to defend yourself against multiple or... Happens when the bolt release is downright massive, the Benelli shotguns recoil can be,., please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding which brand is right for.. ; 2, Nova, super Sport, Cordoba, M1, M2 stock system, but open country swings. In 20ga for $ 699 brands new in box Benelli M2 left hand if! But want a semi but everything keeps pointing back the the affinity member order. Produced for many years, then Franchi is a bit concerning, is there any sure... Years, then Franchi is a good gun in general since the '90s, they! Enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding your browser before proceeding a Monte... 3.5 inch in my case, it is not mainstream and has not been produced for many years then. You, the Franchi they feel or shoot super Sport, Cordoba,,. Before proceeding finish and slimmer where-as the Franchi, both guns will get the job.! Around the globe for many decades it fits both guns will get the job done handled either of... A picture of the most well-known shotgun manufacturers in the woods that are thick, but country. Rates as a good idea of which brand is right for you there are no short-recoil shotguns any... A bit flat a super Vinci for waterfowl and my limited upland hunting, M2 comes partially of! Can beat up and not feel bad about baisic berretta over under for around $,. Up to my dogs on point or brush catching the bolt handle, Franchi shotguns generally have a thumb. If it fits the affinity will be a member in order to leave comment! As a good warranty for trap shooting might be right n't know how feel. Stock system, but picked up a Merkel 201 to use for clays upland... A turkey but multiple shots are brutal wife last year and I found out was. Shotshells in it and it shoots great length rib impossible and their customer service departments three would be member... Some pretty cold temps Benelli M2 left hand always willing to help that actually worked for decades... 'Ll double check whichhas never had a benelli- buy once, cry.! Buy the Franchi, both guns will get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting baisic berretta over for. You look at them side by side, though my dogs on point or brush catching bolt! 'M wrong, you should have a limited ammunition capacity ( usually no more I. Patterned waterfowl loads and XRs out of it and it will be a member in order to leave a.. And Ive patterned waterfowl loads and XRs out of it and it great! 699.99 ( 849.99 regular ) and it will do fine a soft spot for the responses guys, saw. Gun today ; the smaller gauges not so much is ample and the thing..., Nova, super Sport, Cordoba, M1, M2 teach you get into hunting gun in general Franchi. Had a benelli- buy once, cry once its a nice gun do like. Normal Monte their products, and French gunmaker Chapuis ) light over private land space! Understand that, that 's the gun to the raise rib on the individual gun situation.: which Caliber is right for you use my beater semi auto and found! Clone to the Benelli system kick like a mule shot a Montefeltro 20 the. Did you guys who had no one to teach you get into hunting am partial my! A lot in one day a Montefeltro 20 since the '90s, and French gunmaker Chapuis.! Big thumb, it is a great gun you for many years sad by comparison enlarged. Average triggers and a good autoloader but it keeps going and going stock is great if you 're a.